← Back to the Hall of Fame
Vaulted

Captain Jack

Captain Jack

No wonder the rum's always gone! Lightly spiced with mashed bananas and chopped banana chips and coated in a brown sugar dark rum glaze.

We never brought this cookie back as its brother, Bananakin Skywalker, has always been more popular.

Additionally, the moisture in this cookie was really overwhelming and difficult to handle!

First Released: April 2024
🔒 Not Eligible for Voting
Captain Jack

More From the Hall of Fame

See the full lineup →
24 Carrot Magic
24 Carrot Magic
Vaulted
Our spin on carrot cake: browned butter, toasted carrots, pecans, oats, and raisins mixed...
Check It Out 👉
 Bananakin Skywalker
Bananakin Skywalker
Vaulted
In our top 5, and most people would agree. A banana walnut chocolate chip...
Check It Out 👉
 Basic White Girl
Basic White Girl
Vaulted
Don't be fooled - this cookie is anything but basic! A spiced pumpkin cookie...
Check It Out 👉
 Berrilyn Monroe
Berrilyn Monroe
Vaulted
A decadent, creamy blend of real strawberries and hand-chopped real white chocolate. 
Check It Out 👉
 Bourbon Pecan Pie
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Vaulted
A rich shortbread cookie led by browned butter and toasted sugar. Topped with an...
Check It Out 👉
 Brookie of the Year
Brookie of the Year
Vaulted
Half Cookie. Half Brownie. 100% worth the hype.We combined two of our greatest creations...
Check It Out 👉
 Cereal Killer
Cereal Killer
Vaulted
Formerly known as "Yabba Dabba Dough", he used to be innocent...Then, the sugar got...
Check It Out 👉
 Cinnamon Roll
Cinnamon Roll
This Week Only
A cinnamon roll in cookie form. This cookie is incredible, but SO much work....
🛒 Shop Now
 Cranberry Orange Pecan
Cranberry Orange Pecan
Vaulted
This cookie is a work of art. It features a crisp breeze of dried...
Check It Out 👉
 Cream Abdul Jabbar
Cream Abdul Jabbar
Vaulted
A cookie so legendary, it damn well BETTER be in the Hall of Fame. This...
Check It Out 👉
 Crisp Hemsworth
Crisp Hemsworth
Vaulted
Apple crisp, but make it sexy. Packed with cinnamon, caramelized Honeycrisp apples, and oat...
Check It Out 👉
 Fresh Tart
Fresh Tart
Vaulted
One of the most-raved-about cookies in KC history. A buttery lemon shortbread cookie filled...
Check It Out 👉
 Gingy Weasley
Gingy Weasley
Vaulted
A fiery ginger spiced cookie with Callebaut white chocolate and dried cranberries.
Check It Out 👉
 Gluten Free Chocolate Chip
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip
Vaulted
"That doesn't even taste Gluten-Free." You know how many times we hear this every...
Check It Out 👉
 Island Boy
Island Boy
Vaulted
Pineapple Upside Down Cake Cookie! We do this once a year for our birthday....
Check It Out 👉
 Kernel Cornbread
Kernel Cornbread
Vaulted
We've had tons of people ask us for the recipe to this one.A blend...
Check It Out 👉
 Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Pie
Vaulted
Perhaps our most impressive creation yet. Key lime pie, but make it cookie. This...
Check It Out 👉
 Magic Mike
Magic Mike
Vaulted
Inspired by 7-layer bars (or "magic bars"), this cookie is filled with dark chocolate,...
Check It Out 👉
 Mama's Boy
Mama's Boy
Vaulted
A rich brownie-based cookie packed with chocolate and peanut butter chips and filled with...
Check It Out 👉
 'Merica M&M
'Merica M&M
Vaulted
Our limited 4th of July cookie — loaded with red, white, and blue M&Ms...
Check It Out 👉
 Mon Cheri
Mon Cheri
Vaulted
Our most chocolatey creation yet!A sexy, fudgy cookie freckled with dried cherries and bursting with an...
Check It Out 👉
 Mr. Alejandro
Mr. Alejandro
Vaulted
Crispety, crunchety! This cookie is made with browned butter and chock-full of semisweet chips...
Check It Out 👉
 Mr. Chocolate
Mr. Chocolate
Vaulted
Our original chocolate chip cookie, but brushed with melted chocolate on the bottom.A nod...
Check It Out 👉
View the Full Hall of Fame →