← Back to the Hall of Fame
Vaulted

Mr. Chocolate

Mr. Chocolate

Our original chocolate chip cookie, but brushed with melted chocolate on the bottom.

A nod to the great Jacques Torres. We stopped doing this one because the cruel Austin sun doesn't agree with it 🥲

First Released: February 2024
🔒 Not Eligible for Voting
Mr. Chocolate

More From the Hall of Fame

See the full lineup →
24 Carrot Magic
24 Carrot Magic
Vaulted
Our spin on carrot cake: browned butter, toasted carrots, pecans, oats, and raisins mixed...
Check It Out 👉
 Bananakin Skywalker
Bananakin Skywalker
Vaulted
In our top 5, and most people would agree. A banana walnut chocolate chip...
Check It Out 👉
 Basic White Girl
Basic White Girl
Vaulted
Don't be fooled - this cookie is anything but basic! A spiced pumpkin cookie...
Check It Out 👉
 Berrilyn Monroe
Berrilyn Monroe
Vaulted
A decadent, creamy blend of real strawberries and hand-chopped real white chocolate. 
Check It Out 👉
 Bourbon Pecan Pie
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Vaulted
A rich shortbread cookie led by browned butter and toasted sugar. Topped with an...
Check It Out 👉
 Brookie of the Year
Brookie of the Year
Vaulted
Half Cookie. Half Brownie. 100% worth the hype.We combined two of our greatest creations...
Check It Out 👉
 Captain Jack
Captain Jack
Vaulted
No wonder the rum's always gone! Lightly spiced with mashed bananas and chopped banana...
Check It Out 👉
 Cereal Killer
Cereal Killer
Vaulted
Formerly known as "Yabba Dabba Dough", he used to be innocent...Then, the sugar got...
Check It Out 👉
 Cinnamon Roll
Cinnamon Roll
This Week Only
A cinnamon roll in cookie form. This cookie is incredible, but SO much work....
🛒 Shop Now
 Cranberry Orange Pecan
Cranberry Orange Pecan
Vaulted
This cookie is a work of art. It features a crisp breeze of dried...
Check It Out 👉
 Cream Abdul Jabbar
Cream Abdul Jabbar
Vaulted
A cookie so legendary, it damn well BETTER be in the Hall of Fame. This...
Check It Out 👉
 Crisp Hemsworth
Crisp Hemsworth
Vaulted
Apple crisp, but make it sexy. Packed with cinnamon, caramelized Honeycrisp apples, and oat...
Check It Out 👉
 Fresh Tart
Fresh Tart
Vaulted
One of the most-raved-about cookies in KC history. A buttery lemon shortbread cookie filled...
Check It Out 👉
 Gingy Weasley
Gingy Weasley
Vaulted
A fiery ginger spiced cookie with Callebaut white chocolate and dried cranberries.
Check It Out 👉
 Gluten Free Chocolate Chip
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip
Vaulted
"That doesn't even taste Gluten-Free." You know how many times we hear this every...
Check It Out 👉
 Island Boy
Island Boy
Vaulted
Pineapple Upside Down Cake Cookie! We do this once a year for our birthday....
Check It Out 👉
 Kernel Cornbread
Kernel Cornbread
Vaulted
We've had tons of people ask us for the recipe to this one.A blend...
Check It Out 👉
 Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Pie
Vaulted
Perhaps our most impressive creation yet. Key lime pie, but make it cookie. This...
Check It Out 👉
 Magic Mike
Magic Mike
Vaulted
Inspired by 7-layer bars (or "magic bars"), this cookie is filled with dark chocolate,...
Check It Out 👉
 Mama's Boy
Mama's Boy
Vaulted
A rich brownie-based cookie packed with chocolate and peanut butter chips and filled with...
Check It Out 👉
 'Merica M&M
'Merica M&M
Vaulted
Our limited 4th of July cookie — loaded with red, white, and blue M&Ms...
Check It Out 👉
 Mon Cheri
Mon Cheri
Vaulted
Our most chocolatey creation yet!A sexy, fudgy cookie freckled with dried cherries and bursting with an...
Check It Out 👉
 Mr. Alejandro
Mr. Alejandro
Vaulted
Crispety, crunchety! This cookie is made with browned butter and chock-full of semisweet chips...
Check It Out 👉
View the Full Hall of Fame →